Easy Coconut Pumpkin Pie Recipe

This pumpkin pie is made with coconut milk in the filling and coconut flakes in the crust. The coconut adds a smooth cooling flavor that complement the warm cinnamon, ginger and other pumpkin spices. This coconut pumpkin pie recipe is my favorite variation of pumpkin pie that I rarely make my classic pumpkin pie recipe anymore.

Ingredients for Coconut Pumpkin Pie

Pumpkin Puree

You can use canned pumpkin or fresh pumpkin for this pie. I like to cook a pumpkin or two at the beginning of the fall season and freeze my pumpkin puree for all my pumpkin recipes throughout the festive months. If you are using a whole pumpkin check out my post on how to make pumpkin puree.

Coconut Milk

I use Thai Kitchen canned unsweetened coconut milk. Not the cream, not the sweetened milk just the regular unsweetened milk. The coconut milk is the only ingredient in the filling to give us a coconut flavor. If you want the coconut flavor to be stronger I suggest putting 1/2 a cup of coconut flakes in your pie crust. This will give you the coconut flavor throughout the whole pie.

Sugar

Sugar is our sweetener, you can substitute with a 1:1 ratio of Monk Fruit Sweetener. I have never tired to substitute honey or maple syrup for this pumpkin pie recipe but I believe it could be done. If you do try consider reducing the milk by 1/4 of a cup to make up for the added moisture.

I like to use organic cane sugar from Azure Standard. If you’ve never heard from azure standard before you should check our my Azure Standard Review to learn more.

Eggs

Eggs are a binding agent in baking as well as adding a creamy texture from the rich egg yoke.

Spices

Our spices include cinnamon, nutmeg, ginger. These spices add so much flavor and you can easily adjust the amounts and create a whole new flavor. If you favor one flavor over the other you can experiment by adding a extra 1/4 teaspoon to the spice you want to stand out. Reduce another spice you want to be more subtle then the others.

I also really like freshly ground nutmeg. This is optional but if you have never tried grating your own nutmeg from whole cloves you are missing out. I love the taste of nutmeg and fresh nutmeg does not disappoint

Salt

Enhance the flavor with good salt like Redmond Real Salt. If you are looking for a unrefined natural salt with multiple minerals and electrolytes harvested in the United States of America, then look no further. Redmond Real Salt is full of flavor and nutrients and harvested out of the ancient seabed deep beneath Central Utah.

Cornstarch/Flour

We don’t need much but just a little flour or cornstarch mixed in to our pie batter thickens our pie just enough to keep hold our pie together, especially when we cut into it.

How To Make Coconut Pumpkin Pie

Make a Pie Crust

With whatever pie crust you choose add 1/2 a cup of coconut flakes in the same time you add the flour. This will give our pie a more rounded coconut flavor.

Mix Wet Ingredients Together

In a bowl mix together the pumpkin, eggs, and coconut milk till smooth

Add Dry Ingredients

Then add the sugar, spices and cornstarch or flour. Mix until thoroughly combined.

Pour Into Prepared Pie Crust

In a 9 inch pie pan prepare you crust and then pour you coconut pumpkin filling into your unbaked prepared pie crust.

Bake

Bake at 400 degree for 10 minutes then reduce the heat to 350 for 35 minutes. I recommend placing a crust shield on at the same time you reduce the heat. The shield will protect the edge of your crust from burning while the center of the pie continues to cook.

Let Cool and Serve

Take the pie out of the oven when the middle no longer jiggles when the pie is moved. That is how you will know it is cooked all the way through. Let the pie cool for at least 1 hour, I’d personally give it 3 hours before cutting into it. Serve with homemade whipped cream or a fresh glass of eggnog and enjoy!

Shop This Post!